When tragic stories fill the news bulletins, it’s understandable how we often turn to crime fiction for our answers.
Over 100 years since the release of her first novel, Agatha Christie remains the most popular author of all time. Crime fiction in general, has never been so in demand, both in novels and on TV. For those of us who write in the crime genre, this popularity will come as no real surprise. I have never felt that an interest in the crimes we commit against one another was prurient or unpleasant. In fact, recent news stories have helped me to better understand this need we seem to have to create stories about what can sometimes seem the darkest corners of the human experience.
Over the past few weeks, few of us could have missed the series of tragic news stories that have broken in the UK. A missing mother of young children and the horrific murder of a woman and her child. The majority of us have been shocked and deeply saddened by these events. With some individuals not content with venting their opinions on these cases online, vigilante groups have even taken it upon themselves to actively investigate leads themselves. A completely misguided action, of course, likely to cause more harm than good. However, the frustration the general public feels when reading about these tragedies from afar isn’t difficult to understand.
With news coming to us seemingly in real time through our social media, with us being able to comment on a BBC News or Sky News tweet, it feels as if we can all offer our own armchair expertise. Despite criminology being a skill requiring years of specialist training, many of us feel our own judgement on the snippets of information we have been fed by press releases means we have something crucial to add. Don’t get me wrong, I’m guilty of exactly the same speculation, although I hope I have the sensitivity to keep it to myself, or amongst my nearest and dearest only.
Added to this sense of frustration, based on good intentions and a genuine desire to help or prevent such tragedies in future, have come the recent reports of corruption, misogyny and even criminality within parts of the UK police force itself. These cases, even if they are being weeded out and dealt with, will no doubt erode our trust in the organisations dedicated to protecting us from the worst of crimes. The majority of us realise that taking action into our own hands is foolish and damaging, so how do we vent this natural frustration and curiosity relating to the crimes that we seem not to be able to explain or prevent? Well, I believe we absorb ourselves in well-researched and cleverly plotted crime fiction instead.
As a reader and viewer myself, I would love to think that somebody like Vera Stanhope or Inspector Morse were in charge of some of the real-life cases we have been hearing about in recent years. We want to know that violent criminals are being hunted down by intelligent, sensitive and fundamentally decent individuals – the DI Rebus’s and the DCI Jane Tennisons. They often have to deal with corruption in their own ranks, but the skills and innate goodness of the lead detective means that the bad apples are removed swiftly and without destroying the trust we have in the crime fighting community as a whole.
For me, when I am frustrated by cases in the news that I cannot make sense of or hope to solve, I find that reading and writing about crime helps to satisfy that basic human need for justice and closure which is at the heart of this internal disquiet. We want missing people to be found, we want to know where they went and why. When tragedy strikes, we want explanations and justice to be done. This is not always possible in the real world. But in the fictional world, it is a necessity.
I really hope it doesn’t come across as crass or trite that I am conflating such awful real-life cases with crime fiction. That is really not my intention. Crime books aren’t real, or even particularly important in the grand scheme of things. They are pieces of entertainment, first and foremost, but I also feel they perform an important role in helping us to make some kind of sense of a world that often seems bleak and without satisfactory answers.
I believe the enduring popularity of crime stories is not a result of us being voyeuristic or cruel, but rather, because we care. We are still powerless to make the cases in the news better, but we can assuage our frustration and disquiet in a safe space created by fictional scenarios where we always get the answers. In the real world, these answers may well never be found.